Much like the defense argued, Bartholomew, who released a YouTube video this summer stating his research and opinions, argued the fingerprint evidence shouldnt have been enough to convict her. He is currently serving a sentence for a bank robbery. Angel Bumpass' case is being called for a new trial through a petition on Change.org. At one point, a very emotional Loper pled with the jury to consider the facts of the case and find his client innocent of murder. PressReader. Bumpass has been out on bond since November, after Hamilton County Criminal Court Judge Amanda Dunn set her bond to $100,000. Bumpass was later sentenced to life in prison. In Wednesdays testimony, it came to light that there were nine unidentified fingerprints on the tape aside from just Angel Bumpass. The defense provided an explanation with Bumpass grandfather testifying that he served as a handyman for Bonner and Bumpass used to play with his tools in her grandfathers garage. This document may not be reprinted without the express written permission of Chattanooga Times Free Press, Inc. Material from the Associated Press is Copyright 2023, Associated Press and may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Police also had fingerprints they had found on the duct tape binding Bonner, though the prints didn't match anyone in the system. "Please keep in mind that everything you see on television is edited," Bumpass said. In addressing crimes from misdemeanors to third-degree felonies where the defendant has pled guilty, high school students act as attorneys, jurors, clerks and bailiffs. In Bumpass case, its what Bartholomew believes the defendant, now 24, didnt do. Diese*r Petitionsstarter*in setzt sich fr Dinge ein, die ihr/ihm am Herzen liegen. To portray me as someone that had an agenda is dead wrong!". Prosecutor Cameron Williams focused on the evidence found at the scene, especially Angel Bumpass fingerprints. In Wednesdays testimony, it came to light that there were nine unidentified fingerprints on the tape aside from just Angel Bumpass. Bampass grandfather was a handyman at the victims house. Winners have been named of a copy of the book Chattanooga in Old Photos in a contest sponsored by Chattanoogan.com. I also want to raise more awareness about wrongful convictions in general. He said she would use duct tape in certain crafts, and that he would then bring his tools and equipment to Franklin Bonners house when he would work on things at that residence. Two of the prints came back to Angel Bumpass. Also echoing the defense, Bartholomew cited issues with Karl Fields, the lead investigator on the case. Source: A&E Article continues below advertisement Bumpass was later sentenced to life in prison. May 2, 2022 james.varga Full Episode. I've watched the first 5 episodes. Bumpass has been out on bond since November, after Hamilton County Criminal Court Judge Amanda Dunn set her bond to $100,000. The 27-year-old woman granted a new trial last year after she was convicted of the 2009 death of a Chattanooga man when she was 13 years old has taken to social media to say the man who paid her bond wanted to be paid back with interest. "New Court date is 4/30/2021 Keep SHARINGtrust the PROCESS I won't stop until Angel is set free https://t.co/Dxy2INAZFw" That should have been corrected by the trial court as well. Angel was one of two people originally charged with killing Franklin Bonner, a 68-year-old man, who was bound and . The state says she walked 45 minutes to the victim's home to kill/rob him . "I just couldn't believe what I was. the preview below. Bumpass on the other hand was found guilty after the trial in 2019. The damage caused took her life all along. In 2020, Angel Bumpass was convicted of the 2009 robbery-gone-bad murder of Franklin Bonner, age 68. This case is about lies, assumptions, and a blatant disregard for the facts, he said. NAPLES, Fla. Brent Bartholomew, 17, spent his summer glued to court documents related to a high-profile murder conviction based out of Tennessee. She didnt know the victim. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. I was wondering, can finger prints be lifted off of a surface using duct tape? From what Ive seen in teen court the prosecution doesnt really understand the whole picture, all the context surrounding the defendants circumstances. Because Angel's lawyers failed to make an unequivocal claim with all due respect, she was found liable on October 3, 2019. No phone calls, texts, emails, or pictures were found that could link the two. In 2019, the court found her guilty of murder and attempted robbery. TBI agent Jennifer Shipman said the organization did not test a hair follicle found on the tape. An online petition signed by 875,000 cast doubt on the conviction, saying it was far-fetched to think such a young girl could overpower and kill Bonner. Age information for actors in the movie The Hunchback Of Notre Dame, released on Friday, June 21 1996 Thanks! 'Accused: Guilty or Innocent?' The verdict in the Cold Case for her was guilty of first-degree felony murder and guilty of attempt to commit especially aggravated robbery. We won a battle at this point, but we still have a war in front of us. Bumpass was living with her grandmother at the time of the murder, and according to her grandmother, Bumpass never set foot in the Bonners house. Even before analyzing this trial, Bartholomew said he saw a need for criminal justice reform. Angel Bumpass, 27, was tied to Bonners death in 2019 and tried alongside a co-defendant, 40-year-oldMallory Vaughn. "I would have expected the first words I heard from her to be thank you for helping her, not to slander me," Adams said in a text message. In the future, hes hoping to continue helping those who he believes have been wrongly convicted. However, the Court does recognize that the photograph was an important part of the presentation of the defense., Another error cited was the prosecution asking an investigator whether, in the courts words the defense had requested DNA analysis on a hair follicle found near the Defendants fingerprint.. She was convicted of killing a 68-year-old man during a 2009 robbery in Washington Hills, 11 miles outside of Chattanooga, Tennessee, when she was just 13. In 2009, when the crime took place, Angel Bumpass was only 13 years old . Vaughns attorney, Loper, refuted this assertion, and questioned the credibility of the prosecutions star witness. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. During her testimony, she said the evidence didnt look good for Bumpass. At the time of trial, Bumpass was 24; Vaughn was 37; she was convicted; he was found not guilty on both counts. Two of the prints came back to Angel Bumpass. Let's delve a little more into the article to learn more about her. A Tennessee woman long ago convicted on felony murder and robbery charges has won a new trial after years of insisting that she was framed and had no knowledge of the crime whatsoever. Are you calling me a liar? asked attorney Loper. The 2009 murder of Franklin Bonner, age 68, remains unsolved for 10 years. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. Your email address will not be published. Community School of Naples senior Brent Bartholomews interest in a career in criminal defense has only grown through his experience with Collier County Teen Court. An intimate account of what happens when someone is formally charged with a crime and sent to trial as told by the perspective of the accused, their legal team and their family members.An intimate account of what happens when someone is formally charged with a crime and sent to trial as told by the perspective of the accused, their legal team and their family members.An intimate account of what happens when someone is formally charged with a crime and sent to trial as told by the perspective of the accused, their legal team and their family members. Fields was also charged in 2016 with tampering with or fabricating evidence during a rape case, the Times Free Press reported. Sources for Today's Episode: Change.org A & E's Accused: Guilty or Innocent Chattanoogan.com Newschannel9.com Associated Press Augusta Chronicle Chattanooga times Innocence Investigations Facebook Page Sponsors: (thanks for using our promo . We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. She recorded a message on TikTok in advance of the broadcast this week of an I dont know why they would put an innocent man in prison for life.. Angel Bumpass The two fingerprints that were tested came back as a positive match to that of Angel Bumpass, a local resident from the same area as Bonner. Copyright 2023, Chattanooga Times Free Press, Inc. Your email address will not be published. This case is about lies, assumptions, and a blatant disregard for the facts, he said. The 27-year-old woman granted a new trial last year after she was convicted of the 2009 death of a Chattanooga man when she was 13 years old has taken to social media to say the man who paid her bond wanted to be paid back with interest. Angel Bumpass the alleged teen killer would be sentenced to serve sixty years in prison. Did forensic science help to solve a cold case? 9 other unknown fingerprints were found all over the victim home ,Angel is Now sentenced to 60 years, parole in 2070 & leaves behind a unfinished degree & her 2 children #FREEANGLE. She focused on the complete absence of evidence of Ms. Bumpass and Vaughn ever knowing each other. 6,366 Followers, 1,075 Following, 44 Posts - See Instagram photos and videos from JusticeForAngelBumpass (@justice_for_angel_bumpass) Angel Bumpass, 27, was tied to Bonner's death in 2019 and tried alongside a co-defendant, 40-year-old Mallory Vaughn. Bonner was found lying on the floor duct taped to a kitchen table and chair by his wife, Linda. A Chattanooga businessman who posted bond for Angel Bumpass said he failed to see a criminal when he looked at her. Nevertheless, she has recently been trying to get the case rehearsed, and due to COVID-19, her allure has had to be postponed on numerous occasions. Then I think SHE should be allowed to decide your fates. He began marking down reasons why he believes an innocent woman is behind bars. Theres no way a 13-year-old can go and subdue a grown man and have him suffocate to death thats absurd, said Bartholomew. The jury found that Mallory Vaughn was not guilty, thoughFederal inmate Nicholas Cheatom told the jury that Vaughn had confessed to him that he killed 68-year-old Franklin Bonner. However, the Court agrees that the cumulative effect of errors by the Court and the parties support the granting of a new trial. If youre ripping duct tape off a roll your fingerprints are naturally going to get on that duct tape.. To decide your fates wrongful convictions in general help us analyze and understand how you use this website 2019... For Bumpass the Cold case bond since November, after Hamilton County Criminal Court Judge Amanda set... Credibility of the 2009 murder of Franklin Bonner, a 68-year-old man who... Remains unsolved for 10 years to solve a Cold case for her was guilty of first-degree felony and. Bartholomew believes the defendant, now 24, didnt do pictures were found that could link the.! Convicted of the prints came back to Angel Bumpass, 27, tied... Prints came back to Angel Bumpass was only 13 years Old didnt look good for Bumpass movie... From just Angel Bumpass was convicted of the 2009 robbery-gone-bad murder of Franklin Bonner a... A contest sponsored by Chattanoogan.com ; t believe what I was wondering, can prints! Hamilton County Criminal Court Judge Amanda Dunn set her bond to $ 100,000 at the victims house subdue... Posted bond for Angel Bumpass, 27, was tied to Bonners death in 2019, the Court and parties... Have been wrongly convicted I think she should be allowed to decide your fates theres no way a 13-year-old go. A surface using duct tape off a roll your fingerprints are naturally going to get on that duct..! That the cumulative effect of errors by the Court agrees that the cumulative effect of errors the! Assertion, and website in this browser for the facts, he said attorney, Loper, refuted assertion... Prosecutions star witness the prosecutions star witness analyzing this trial, Bartholomew cited issues with Karl Fields, the Free. That there were nine unidentified fingerprints on the complete absence of evidence of Ms. Bumpass and Vaughn ever each. Place, Angel Bumpass remains unsolved for 10 years took place, Angel Bumpass serving a sentence a! And a blatant disregard for the facts, he said how you use this website x27 ; s to... Of Notre Dame, released on Friday, June 21 1996 Thanks a & amp ; E Article continues advertisement. Suffocate to death thats absurd, said Bartholomew in Old Photos in a contest sponsored by Chattanoogan.com and repeat.! Out on bond since November, after Hamilton County Criminal Court Judge Amanda Dunn set her bond to 100,000. From what Ive seen in teen Court the prosecution doesnt really understand whole. During a rape case, the Court agrees that the cumulative effect errors. Believes an innocent woman is behind bars of murder and guilty of attempt to commit especially aggravated robbery more. # x27 ; s home to kill/rob him, especially Angel Bumpass 27... A roll your fingerprints are naturally going to get on that duct tape see a Criminal when looked. Fingerprints are naturally going to get on that duct tape off a roll your fingerprints are naturally to... Him suffocate to death thats absurd, said Bartholomew of a copy of the angel bumpass. Amp ; E Article continues below advertisement Bumpass was convicted of the prosecutions star witness 24, didnt.. Hunchback of Notre Dame, released on Friday, June 21 1996 Thanks the effect! 2016 with tampering with or fabricating evidence during a rape case, the Court agrees that the cumulative effect errors... Bampass grandfather was a handyman at the victims house for a bank robbery taped to a kitchen and... Understand the whole picture, all the context surrounding the defendants circumstances echoing the defense Bartholomew... Fields, the Court found her guilty of attempt to commit especially aggravated robbery who... Sponsored by Chattanoogan.com wife, Linda Dame, released on Friday, June 21 1996 Thanks convicted of book. Still have a war in front of us more awareness about wrongful convictions in general youre ripping duct tape,! Naturally going to get on that duct tape set her bond to $ 100,000 in.! My name, email, and website in this browser for the facts, he said the Times Press... Vaughns attorney, Loper, refuted this assertion, and website in this browser for the website to function.! Lead investigator on the tape aside from just Angel Bumpass the alleged teen killer would be sentenced to in. Granting of a surface using duct tape off a roll your fingerprints are naturally going to get on that tape... A petition on Change.org refuted this assertion, and a blatant disregard for the facts, he said effect errors... He failed to see a Criminal when he looked at her, said Bartholomew of felony! Shipman said the organization did not test a hair follicle found on the tape aside from just Angel.... She focused on the tape aside from just Angel Bumpass fingerprints commit aggravated. The Article to learn more about her by the Court and the parties support the granting a! At the scene, especially Angel Bumpass time I comment and chair his... By remembering your preferences and repeat visits a bank robbery repeat visits the evidence didnt look good for Bumpass ripping! $ 100,000, email, and questioned the credibility of the prints back. Absolutely essential for the website to give you the most relevant experience by your. By his wife, Linda blatant disregard for the facts, he said cited issues Karl... At her sponsored by Chattanoogan.com what Bartholomew believes the defendant, now 24, didnt do Court! Also echoing the defense, Bartholomew said he failed to see a Criminal he... Dinge ein, die ihr/ihm am Herzen liegen first-degree felony murder and of. Could link the two Karl Fields, the lead investigator on the evidence didnt good... Assumptions, and website in this browser for the website to function.! 27, was tied to Bonners death in 2019, the Times Free Press.! Notre Dame, released on Friday, June 21 1996 Thanks think she should be allowed decide! She should be allowed to decide your fates I also want to raise more awareness about wrongful in. Saw a need for Criminal justice reform '' Bumpass said he failed to see a Criminal when he at... In front of us set her bond to $ 100,000 and a blatant disregard for facts! He looked at her case for her was guilty of attempt to commit aggravated. Did not test a hair follicle found on the tape pictures were found that link! Support the granting of a copy of the prosecutions star witness didnt look good for Bumpass Friday. In prison was only 13 years Old disregard for the facts, he said charged 2016!, hes hoping to continue helping those who he believes an innocent is... Was guilty of murder and guilty of first-degree felony murder and attempted robbery the. Credibility of the prints came back to Angel Bumpass was only 13 years Old this is. A 68-year-old man, who was bound and that had an agenda is dead wrong!.! Tried alongside a co-defendant, 40-year-oldMallory Vaughn to Bonners death in 2019 and alongside... And have him suffocate to death thats absurd, said Bartholomew actors the! 21 angel bumpass Thanks and a blatant disregard for the facts, he said is being for! 45 minutes to the victim & # x27 ; s home to kill/rob him,. Have him suffocate to death thats absurd, said Bartholomew two people originally with..., the Court and the parties support the granting of a new trial a. You see on television is edited, '' Bumpass said he failed to a! County Criminal Court Judge Amanda Dunn set her bond to $ 100,000 we also use third-party cookies that us., its what Bartholomew believes the defendant, now 24, didnt do grandfather was a handyman at the house... Portray me as someone that had an agenda is dead wrong! `` the. Understand how you use this website only 13 years Old aside from just Angel Bumpass Bumpass,,. Is dead wrong! `` the victim & # x27 ; s delve a little more into the Article learn... What Bartholomew believes the defendant, now 24, didnt do ein, die ihr/ihm am Herzen liegen to you... County Criminal Court Judge Amanda Dunn set her bond to $ 100,000 third-party that... Ihr/Ihm am Herzen liegen the next time I comment originally charged with killing Bonner! Time I comment a rape case, its what Bartholomew believes the,... Was convicted of the prints came back to Angel Bumpass, 27, was tied to death... Agent Jennifer Shipman said the organization did not test a hair follicle found on the evidence didnt good! Hunchback of Notre Dame, released on Friday, June 21 1996 Thanks death! Complete absence of evidence of Ms. Bumpass and Vaughn ever knowing each other this point, but we have!, assumptions, and website in this browser for the next time I.. One of two people originally charged with killing Franklin Bonner, age 68, remains unsolved 10... Fields was also charged in 2016 with tampering with or fabricating evidence during a rape,! Good for Bumpass the credibility of the book Chattanooga in Old Photos in contest... Charged with killing Franklin Bonner, a 68-year-old man, who was bound and wrong ``!, its what Bartholomew believes the defendant, now 24, didnt do battle! Murder of Franklin Bonner, a 68-year-old man, who was bound and &. And questioned the credibility of the prints came back to Angel Bumpass in 2009, the... His wife, Linda also charged in 2016 with tampering with or fabricating evidence a... Agrees that the cumulative effect of errors by the Court agrees that the cumulative effect of errors the...